32.9 C
Monrovia
Sunday, May 5, 2024
Home 2022 April

Monthly Archives: April 2022

FDA Suspends Community Forest Leadership Amid Corruption Scandal

0

Top. John Flomo, the chief officer of the Korninga ‘A’ community forest management body, is accused of mismanaging US$76,000.


By Henry B. Gboluma, Jr.


KORNINGA CHIEFDOM, Gbarpolu – The Forestry Development Authority (FDA) has suspended the entire leadership of a community forest in Gbarpolu County for alleged mismanagement of funds.

Earlier this year, three members of the Korninga ‘A’ Community Forest were jailed for allegedly misusing $US76, 000 intended for social benefits but were later freed after the court placed a hold on the case to allow the FDA to handle the issue.

“Having listened to the chiefdom, and based on first-hand information gathered by our field office concerning alleged misuse of money paid to the community by the company, we hereby indefinitely suspend the entire CFMB,” said Weedor Gray, the technical manager for the department of community forestry at a recent meeting.  

“This includes the [ members of the community assembly] and the Executive Committee members,” she added. Comprising representatives of affected towns and villages, the community assembly is the highest decision-maker in community forestry, while the executive committee takes action on behalf of the group.  

The three men accused of corruption are Johnson Flomo, Austin Kamara and Dennis Flomo, They are the chief officer of the community forest management body (CFMB), and chairman and co-chair of the executive committee, respectively. The CFMB manages the community forest’s funds and projects.

They are accused of diverting the fund for their own use, thereby depriving the community of its benefit, a violation of the New Panel Code of Liberia, according to court documents. Covieyallah Investment Enterprise, which has had an agreement with the community since April 2019 for logging rights in its 48,296-hectare forest, had paid the money for the construction of schools, roads, and clinics in affected areas in the Bopolu District.

The men deny the accusation, saying they spent the money on motorcycles, training, a traditional ceremony, a Christmas party, fees for a lawyer and transportation to and from Monrovia.

Gray indicated that the suspended team would be prosecuted if an audit of the community forest’s fund found them guilty of corruption, adding that the move was a message to the rest of the CFMBs in the country.   

George Sumo, the Paramount Chief of the Korninga Chiefdom, will now set up an interim team that will conduct the affairs of the community forest for six months, Gray said. She, however, said the community forests’ bank account will remain frozen until the interim leadership takes over.

“Through this team, we will work with partners and the seven affected communities to vet and establish a new CFMB to manage the Korninga ‘A’ Community Forest to benefit you, the community people,” Gray said.

The Community Rights Law of 2009 with Respect to Forest Lands, which empowers communities to manage their own forests, mandates only the executive committee of a community forest to take charge in cases of mismanagement of community funds but Sumo will occupy the position in the meantime, as the executive committee is implicated in the scandal. “So that is the reason we wrote a letter of no-confidence [in the entire leadership]

“So that is the reason we wrote a letter of no-confidence [in the entire leadership] to FDA for the all of them to be replaced and punished over it,” Sumo said.

This story was a collaboration with the Center for Transparency and Accountability of Liberia (CENTAL), with funding from the Swedish Development Agency (SIDA). It is an activity under the CENTAL’s ongoing National Integrity Building and Anti-Corruption (NIBA) program.

Indonesia Palm Oil Exports Ban Hurts Liberia Amid Ukrainian War

0

Top: Indonesia exported US$26.3 million in palm oil and products made from the commodity to Liberia in 2020, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By Varney Kamara

MONROVIA – Indonesia has banned palm oil exports, a move that will hurt Liberia, which imports the commodity and some of its products from that Asian country. The ban comes amidst the Russian-Ukrainian War, which has cut off supplies of wheat and other agricultural products from the two warring countries to Liberia and other places around the world.

Indonesia imposed the ban on Friday following a series of demonstrations over soaring food prices in the southeastern Asian nation due to the conflict in Ukraine. President Joko Widodo said the ban was to ensure there was food at home for its 278,704,795 people.

“I will monitor and evaluate the implementation of this policy so availability of cooking oil in the domestic market becomes abundant and affordable,” said  Widodo as per the Reuters news agency. “This move is rather unfortunate and totally unexpected.”

The ban means that Liberia has to look elsewhere, as the West African country has been a major importer of palm oil and palm oil products from Indonesia. Data from 2020, the latest available, shows that the Asian state exported US$26.3 million to Liberia, including US$19.1 million in palm oil, US$2.59 million in soap, and US$1.04 million in margarine. In the last 25 years, Indonesian export to Liberia has increased from US$1.38 million in 1995 to US$26.3 million in 2020, representing an increment of 12.5 percent, according to the Observatory of Economic Complexity (OEC) visualizes data on global exports.

The ban is also going to have an indirect impact on Liberia.

Indonesia accounts for more than half of global palm oil supplies, producing 44,500 metric tons of crude palm oil last year, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. That means supplies cuts for big companies such as Nestle SA which exports household products worldwide, including to Liberia.

In 2020, Russia and Ukraine exported a combined US$15.7 million to Liberia, according to Trading Economics, which provides global trade data and forecasts. But those supplies have ceased to come, as the two former Soviet states battle. Ukraine’s export has been halted as the war is on its soil, while Russia has been slapped with a barrage of international sanctions over its unprovoked war against its neighbor.

The world bank estimates that countries that import rice, corn and wheat will be hurt by global supplies spikes as a result of austerity measures in the U.S., structural slowdown in China and the war in Ukraine.

Opinion: Earth Day – A Call To Government To Save Liberia’s Forest

0

Top: Fog forms over a montane forest in Zorzor, Lofa County. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By Gabriel M. Dixon

Today, the world celebrates Earth Day. Every year, people from more than160 countries across the world come together at different events to observe the day.  This year’s celebration is being held under the theme: “Invest in our Planet” in recognition of the threats the earth faces, and to raise awareness against their causes.  The day is also celebrated to call the attention of world leaders to the danger humanity is faced with and why we must stop the damage to our planet.

In 1969, US Senator Gaylord Nelson from Wisconsin, organized a demonstration to raise awareness about environmental issues in the United States of America. His action rallied individuals and organizations across the United States in support of his idea and led to the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency by the U.S. government. In 1970 the first Earth Day celebration was held commemorating the efforts of Senator Nelson. The historical event brought together 20 million participants.   By 1990, Earth Day was an event celebrated by more than 140 countries around the globe.

The Earth, according to scientists, is about 4.5 billion years old. With a land surface area of 57.5 million square miles, the Earth is the only planet that supports life in the Milky Galaxy. There are now more than 7.6 billion people whose lives are being supported by our planet. But the earth is also home to other forms of life including plants, animals, and insects. Along with humans, the planet hosts 8.7 million different species that make up its biodiversity.

But the planet is under serious threat and its survival depends on what its inhabitants must do to save it. Evidence provided by scientists shows that the greatest threat to the planet is “global warming, ”which is a rapid increase in the average surface temperature of the Earth. This warming and cooling lead to different climatic conditions around the world, such as average rainfall, and temperature which happens over a long period of time.  Throughout its history, the earth has warmed and cooled itself. But the last 20 years have contributed more to the warming of the earth than any other period in human history. This is because of the many different pressures being driven by human activities such as industrialization, the use of fossil fuels, and deforestation. Scientists agree that deforestation, which is the clearing of land for agriculture, mining, industrial, construction, and other purposes, along with forest degradation now constitutes 10 percent of climate change worldwide.  

In Liberia, forests are being knocked down at an alarming rate. In the last 20 years, the country has lost 4.8kha (kilo hectares) of its forest cover to deforestation, though it prides itself on having the biggest remaining rainforest in the Upper Guinea region. Despite the government passing laws that protect and safeguard forest and land use, the management of natural resources to prevent unsustainable practices and environmental crimes, illegal logging and bad practices by agriculture companies are hindering the realization of commitments it made to the rest of the world. Government corruption and lack of openness are fueling ugly practices that are pushing up climate change impact on rural communities and negatively affecting the livelihoods of poor farmers and fishermen across the country home to much of the world’s diverse array of plants and animals and provide essential natural resources from timber  

As we celebrate World Earth Day, we call on the government of Liberia to double its efforts to combat climate change. The government has to ensure that the right policy actions are taken and robust enforcement mechanisms are adhered to by duty bearers in line with its commitments to the world. In this way, the government will be “investing in our planet.”

A stream in Bondi Mandingo Chiefdom in Bopolu District, Lofa County. The DayLight/Harry Browne

Park Beautiful But Breaks Airport Safety Standards

0

Top: Different sections of the Invincible Sports Park. Picture credit: Knewsonline


By Gabriel M. Dixon


MonroviaIt illuminates the open landscape of the runway of the James Spriggs Payne Airfield. It is coated in sparkling green with courts for basketball, tennis, and volleyball, a small playground and a parking lot. It even contains a museum that pays homage to the glittering football career of President George Mannah Weah.  The Invincible Sports Park is a marvel of recreational beauty.

But an investigation conducted by The DayLight shows the park breaches international aviation standards. It is right within the runway end safety area (RESA), which is the area beyond the end of a runway that is meant to reduce damage to aircraft when picking off or landing. The area enhances the safety of airplanes and it provides greater accessibility for firefighting and rescue equipment during airport incidents.

“An object situated on a runway strip which may endanger aeroplanes should be regarded as an obstacle and should, as far as practicable, be removed,” according to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), a UN body that sets global standards for the aviation industry. In aviation, the runway strip is the combination of a runway and the runway end safety area.

“No fixed object, other than visual aids required for air navigation or those required for aircraft safety purposes and which must be sited on the runway strip,” the ICAO recommendation continues.    

Though the safety area of the airport does not meet ICAO’s recommended standard of 240 meters, it met the mandatory minimum standard requirement of 90 meters. However, that dimension has now been reduced.  

The spot at which the Invincible Sports Park now sits is infamous for aviation accidents, further raising concerns about its safety. In August 1994, a Douglas DC-9 belonging to ADC airlines carrying 82 passengers and 9 crew members, crashed exactly at the spot while landing. Four other plane crashes are associated with the airport:  another ADC airliner in 1995,  one in 1996 and two others earlier on in 1978 and 1989.  

President Weah is firm that his decision to construct the glamorous park in the safety area of the airfield despite the location’s tragic history. He told the opening ceremony of the park last week the project had claimed his attention to repairing the airport.

He said: “I have therefore directed the Liberia Civil Aviation Authority (LCAA) and the management of the airport to draw up plans and to develop a feasibility study for the upgrading of this facility, including the extension of the runway in the direction of the swamp, in order to enable international jet traffic to operate from Spriggs, and the construction of a new access road for both passengers and cargo.”

Weah might have justified the controversial location of the park. However, he opened another Pandora’s box regarding safety and the environment. Expending the runway strip into the mangrove swamp would violate Liberia’s Environmental Protection and Management Law. The law prohibits people from building in wetlands. Furthermore, the swampland the President spoke of is part of the Mesurado Wetlands, which is a protected area under the Ramsar Convention, an international treaty that protects such environments worldwide. Wetlands serve many purposes, including a buffer against storms, a nursing ground for aquatic species and a hideout for endangered species. The Liberian government will have to show the project would not have a negative impact when that time comes in accordance with the law.

At the start of the park project last year, President Weah had said that the park had  “no interference with the airport. The plane will come, the plane will pass, [and] the plane will land,” Weah said in a viral video posted to Facebook in December last year.  

Weah even argued against the commercial status of James Spriggs Payne Airport in that post. “Even the airport they talked about, [planes] come here every five years. It (the James Spriggs Payne Airport) is not a commercial airport. So, here we are, it has nothing to do with the airport,” he said.

Contrary to the President’s claims, the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and the International Air Transport Association (IATA) regard the airport as suitable for commercial flights and the only other paved runway in Liberia, second only to the Roberts International Airport. Spriggs Payne Airport handled limited international flights despite safety concerns during the war.  Scheduled commercial flights resumed in 2008. The airport underwent a major renovation in 2012 and began commercial flights under former President Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf. Elysian Airlines and ASKY Airlines provided services from Monrovia to Banjul, Accra, Freetown, Lagos, and other West African cities.  But these small carriers have since stopped flying to Liberia due to airport safety concerns.  Mission Airlines Fellowship (MAF) currently uses the James Spriggs Payne Airport for domestic flights.         

The Liberian Senate unanimously voted against the project due to safety concerns but later rescinded its decision and approved the project.   

People scavenge the wreckage of the crashed ADC Airlines in 1994, exactly where the Invincible Sports Park now sits. Photo credit: Getty Images/ Patrick Robert-Corbis

The park is the latest twist in a long tale of how successive governments have handled safety standards at the James Spriggs Payne Airport since its establishment in 1950.  Situated in the densely populated district of Sinkor, three miles from central Monrovia, it has had its own share of the ineptitude of the Liberian political landscape.

In the late-1970s, President William R. Tolbert, Jr opted to improve the facility. The government at the time erected a metal fence and barred unauthorized access in a bid to keep it compliant with international best practices. It conducted a feasibility study and planned relocation of adjacent communities, including Wroto Town, Lakpazee, Tweh-Johnsonville and Key Hole.  But that plan never happened, as he was overthrown about this same time in 1980 by future President Samuel K. Doe.  

It was during the regime of President Doe that football became a feature of the airfield. The metal fence erected by his predecessor was vandalized and looted. It became a practice ground for the Invincible Eleven Football Club (IE), with whom, Weah began to ply his trade to international superstardom. Not just football, the airfield was misused, as it became a major footpath that connected the Sinkor communities of Airfield and Old Road. It was sued for open defecation and a dumpsite.

Peacekeepers of the Economic Community of West African States Monitoring Group (ECOMOG) did not help the situation. The airport became a military target for Charles Taylor’s rebel forces. In 1992, the airport was hit multiple times by rockets that destroyed dozens of aircraft and damaged its runway and terminal station.   

Those abuses continued during the regime of President Charles Taylor, who closed down the airport in June 2002, on grounds that it was close to his Congo Town residence.  

In 2012, the administration of President Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf erected a concrete fence around the airport and basic rehabilitation works were completed to bring it to international standards. A signboard at the current location of the Invincible Sports Park brandished the inscriptions: “No Flying Kites” and “No Playing Football.”   

A graphic showing important details about the James Spriggs Payne Airfield. The DayLight/Gabriel M. Dixon

   

Youth Group Sets Standards for Accountability Nationwide

0

Top: The headquarters of the Bassa Youth Congress (BYC) in Buchanan, Grand Bassa County. The DayLight/Varney Kamara


By Varney Kamara

BUCHANAN, Grand Bassa County – In 2014, the Bassa Youth Caucus (BYC) sacked Mathew Bryant, its president, for misapplying a portion of its share of the county social development fund. Bryant had suggested the US$300 be spent on a toilet project but the executive council, which approves projects for the group, did not sanction it.

“I agree that, constitutionally, my decision should have been approved, Bryant, 33, says in an interview with The DayLight, adding he was “shocked” when he learned about his. “I was attending another function in Monrovia when the guys announced my expulsion.”  

Established in 2006 for local development initiatives nationwide, the County Social Development Fund (CSDF) has been marred by corruption,  mismanagement and confusion since its emergence in 2006, undermining its intent of the fund.   In some counties, officials have created bogus companies, dishing out huge sums for projects that have not been implemented.

But this youth group has used its allotment to set standards for the expenditure of the controversial fund. Apart from its internal dismissals, BYC has held accountable high-profile recipients of the fund and has called for general accountability and transparency nationwide.

Created in 2003, BYC is a collection of 35 different youth groups in the west-central, seaside county. Each of its auxiliaries is represented on its executive council, its highest decision-maker. It was formed to “seek, defend, and protect the interest of young people in the county,” according to its website.

‘Harsh and unbending’

Bryant is not the only member to face BYC’s accountability wrath. Last month, Marjuin Eddie, his successor, was suspended indefinitely over a scandal involving USD$2,500 and L$25,000.

Eddie allegedly withdrew US$2,000 from the group’s account without authorization of its executive council and did not capture that transaction in her financial report late last year. The money was a portion of the US$5,000 social development fund it received last year from the Grand Bassa project management committee (PMC), the body that manages the CSDF. Last year, the county received USD$1.529 million from the government of Liberia as its share of the fund. By law, the county is supposed to receive US$2.7 million, with contributions from ArcelorMittal Liberia (AML) and the Liberia Agriculture Company (LAC) as part of their concession agreements, which affect the county. The PMC distributes the fund to communities through a host of groups every year.

BYC had planned to use its last year’s allotment for agriculture activities across districts but Eddie allegedly used the money on a Christmas party, according to Samuel Wilson, the chairman of the executive council.  

Eddie was also accused of mismanaging US$500  Minister of State for Presidential Affairs Nathaniel McGill donated to BYC and a L$25,000 donation from Representative Thomas Goshua of District Number 5, where BYC is headquartered. On March 19 earlier this year, 29 EC members of the BYC voted to indefinitely suspend her, with an instruction to return the missing money. It also suspended Pauline Geegar Barlingar, its financial secretary, for failing to include those transactions in her report.

“We will not sweep this issue under the carpet. We will not bend the rules in the middle of the game,” says Samuel Wilson, chairman of the executive council. “BYC remains harsh and unbending when it comes to the issue of ensuring transparency and accountability. We must practice what we preach in the society.”

Eddie denies any wrongdoing and has filed a complaint at the Second Judicial Circuit Court in Buchanan for her reinstatement.

“The executive council leadership had for undisclosed reasons decided not to reinstate us, which is impeding our functions as executive leaders, and the effectiveness of the youth caucus,” reads the April 1 court filing of the case. “We are pleading with you, your honor and this Honorable Court, to intervene in the matter and ensure that the leadership of the caucus is made to restore our rights, by lifting our suspension so as to enable perform our duties as duly elected members.” She declined to speak to The DayLight while the matter is in court. The court will hear the case on Friday. 

But Barlingar says she received a fair penalty. “During the investigation, I acknowledged that failure on my part to capture the transaction of the USD$2,000 withdrawal in the financial report was an error on my part,” she tells The DayLight in an interview. “I agree to face my suspension. The [executive council’s] action against me was right.”

Whether or not the accusation against Eddie is true, their suspension is a rarity when it comes to the county social development fund. It shows that some institutions are fighting corruption in Liberia, a country that has grappled with the menace since its foundation. The country is ranked 136 out of 180 countries in the world, with a score of 29, climbing just one step above its 2020 ranking, according to the 2021 corruption index report published by Transparency International, a global anti-corruption watchdog.

“Generally, it is a laudable effort for the Bassa youth to ensure transparency and accountability in the society,” says Anderson Miamen, the executive director of the Center for Transparency and Accountability in Liberia (CENTAL), which works with Transparency International. 

“However, there needs to be an independent investigation into this matter. If the investigation proves that people embezzled BYC’s fund, then, whoever is responsible should be prosecuted,” Miamen adds.  

BYC is currently advocating for an audit of the Grand Bassa CSDF. The fund was last audited five years ago, a violation of the Public Financial Management Act of 2009. The budget law lays out how public funds can be spent and accounted for. It says an audit of the fund shall be carried out at the end of each budget year. BYC criticizes county officials for not respecting that part of the law since 2017, demanding an immediate audit of the CSDF.  

“Calling for an audit is the right thing to do because it leads to accountability and development,” says Patrick Sulloe, a representative of the All People One People Intellectual Forum, one of 35 Bassa groups that make up the BYC. “This is one of the mediums through which the voices of the voiceless can be heard.”

Funding for this story was provided by the Green Livelihood Alliance (GLA 2.0) through the Community Rights and Corporate Governance Program of the Sustainable Development Institute. The DayLight maintained complete editorial independence over the story’s content.

Case Compels Company to Settle Logging Dispute With Community

0

Top: A worker labels logs in Akewa’s log field in Beyan Poye Community Forest, Margibi County. Photo credit: Akewa via Facebook


By Emmanuel Sherman

MONROVIA – A forest community in Margibi County has filed a court action to compel a Nigerian company to discuss a settlement in a logging dispute between them.

Beyan Poye Community Forest wants the Commercial Court at the Temple of Justice to mandate Akewa Group of Companies (AGC) to” submit to arbitration by immediately appointing its arbitrator to the arbitration panel,” according to court filings. 

Beyan Poye had evoked an arbitration clause in the pair’s logging agreement in February earlier this year after more than four years of stalemate. The agreement mandates a three-person penal, one each representing the community, the company and the Forestry Development Authority (FDA), to resolve any dispute to be confirmed by a court.

The community had appointed Tomik Vobah, a lawyer, as its representative. And the FDA also appointed Cllr. Joel Elkanah Theoway as its arbitrator more than a week ago. But the company has yet to send its representative, sparking the court action.  

With the matter now in court, Akewa is now expected to designate its representative in 10 days or will have to accept the court’s ruling to allow the two-man penal to decide the matter.

Abigail Funke Odebunmi, AGC’s CEO said she could not comment while the arbitration process was ongoing.

In March 2017 Akewa signed the agreement with Beyan Poye Community Forest to harvest logs in its 33,338-hectare forest in the Gibi District in exchange for roads, schools, clinics and handpumps. Since then, it has not implemented a single project, except a handpump, the court heard. The company owed the community US$4,000 for 2,141.836 cubic meters of log harvested and US$1,697.52 for land rental fees between the periods 2018 to 2021 and failed to honor its corporate social obligation, according to court documents.

“We further inform you that we are resorting to arbitration against AGC as the result of numerous breaches of the March 25, 2017 community forest management agreement and other subsequent agreements, collateral to said agreement,” Jehudi Barnyou, the chief officer of Beyan Poye’s community forest management body said in a letter to Odebunmi in January earlier this year.

AGC has a history of indebtedness to communities and a record of violations of Liberian logging laws.

An investigation conducted by The DayLight about the same time as Barnyou’s letter found the company violated a host of forestry laws and regulations, dating as far back as 2008, and going with impunity.   

It found that the 100 percent Nigerian-owned company was illegally issued a timber sales contract (TSC A2), meant for companies with at least 51 Liberian shareholdings. The company also owes Compound Number One, the community that hosts the forest the Liberian government leased to her.

AGC was involved in the Private Use Permit (PUP) scandal of 2012 in which 2.5 million hectares of forest land or 23 percent of the country’s landmass was illegally given to logging companies. It held one of those illegal PUPs for Gibi District, surprisingly, the same area it would sign the Beyan Poye agreement.   

The company was investigated by the Liberia Revenue Authority (LRA) for using a tax clearance belonging to Tiger Quarry, a mining company, to bid for the Gola Konneh community forest it would win. Now it owes that community in Grand Cape Mount county logging-related payments as well.

Foya Replants Trees To Defeat Deforestation

0

Top: Farmers from Bambudu planting cocoa in the savannah to combat deforestation and climate change in Foya, Lofa County. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By James Harding Giahyue

FOYA, Lofa County – In the 1970s the Liberian government signed an agreement with Agrimenco, an Israeli company, to produce rice and palm oil in the craggy forest on Liberia’s borders with Sierra Leone and Guinea.  Later, the company left, and the Liberia Produce Marketing Corporation (LPMC) took over its plantation, retaining the district’s bread basket status. But by 1989, the Liberian Civil War (1989-2003) broke out and the project was abandoned, leaving behind huge swathes of cleared forestland for the disposal of invasive savannah.  

While the savannah encroached on its once vast forestland, the 14-year conflict pillaged Foya’s infrastructure, and farmers cut down the remaining forest to farm and burn charcoal in the decades afterward. Then population growth and climate change added insult to injury with bushfires, floods, less water and more mouths to feed in this fabled Kissi countryside in the Liberian northwest.

But Foya is reversing its meltdown. A collaboration involving farmers, nongovernmental organizations, construction workers, community leaders, and local officials combines climate-resilient farming methods, replanting trees and a “law” on fire to banish its ghosts. They call it the Foya Production Protection and Inclusion (PPI) compact.

The turnaround began in 2018 after IDH, a Dutch NGO conducted a land-use plan for the district, highlighting its agricultural potential but warning of dire consequences if villagers continue to cut down trees and watch the savannah spread across the land. Since then, farmers here have planted over 50,000 trees in areas once covered by the savannah and along riverbanks, cultivated acres of swampland, and have seen bushfire incidents reduce.

“I think we, in the not-too-distant future,  will regain our status as the breadbasket of Liberia,” Clarence Sandie, the Statutory District Superintendent of Foya, said at the launch of the project last year.

So far, the farmers have planted 20,166 trees on the banks of Wokanyah, a tributary of the Mayo River to prevent flooding, according to the Forestry Development Authority (FDA), which supervises the villagers. Two years ago, the stream broke its banks after a heavy downpour of rain for the very first time, destroying six homes in the Central Rankollie clan, authorities say. Farmers experience water shortage during the dry season, as the water level reduces, and the fish are disappearing.  

“Most of the trees on the banks of the rivers were all cut down for charcoal production, such as the Makona River between Liberia and Guinea and the Mayo River that branches from the Makona River,” says Oliver Korboi of the (FDA). The trees are all aquatic, including uapaca, and cotton trees.

Farmers are involved in the replanting exercise at all stages. They have created the nurseries, nurtured and transplanted the young trees several miles along the Mayo River.

“I joined the project because it will help our farmers,” says Jenneh Korgor, a villager in Chaysenei, a town on the route to the Sierra Leonean border. “[The trees] help with shade and, I will always be part of this program if it continues.”

“It is very much important for us to have trees by the river for shade and to keep the forest to have more fish in the river,” says Justin Fayia, a villager in Menegisua in the Chaysenei area. He did not participate in the planting himself but asked his children to, and provided his farmland for the trees in nurseries.

A volunteer, Jenneh Korgor points to a tree she and other villagers planted on the banks of a river in Foya, Lofa County. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue

“I did that because I know that the trees will help me in the future,” Fayia adds. “I will advise children not to cut the trees because I know within myself they will help them tomorrow.”

Palm Plantation and agroforestry—where farmers plant cocoa and trees together to combat the savannah—are at the heart of the Foya’s resistance. The main idea is to encourage villagers to leave the natural forest and make their own woodland on the grassland, which covers 26 percent of the district’s territory.

Palm trees are characteristic of Foya’s agriculture profile. Before the war, LPMC ran the country’s largest palm oil mill here, serving as a market for hundreds of growers in the district. The farmers want to bring back those days. Forty-three of them in the Waum, Tengia and Rankollie clans have planted 6,400 palm trees, according to the Office of the Superintendent. “Freedom mills,” a locally made, handheld device for making palm oil is driving the resurgence with double yields.

But cocoa farmers enjoy first preference over their palm counterparts because cocoa can grow alongside other crops and fits the idea of growing farms and forests at the same time, authorities say. Under this part of the project, 60 cocoa farmers have planted 22,952 seedlings on plots in the savannah, according to Robert Kettor, who liaises with farmers and the Office of the District Superintendent. The cocoa farmers have also benefited from 31,691 shade and fruit trees (avocados and orange) to transplant cocoa nurseries, Kettor says. Theobroma, a Liberian cocoa firm piloting the idea of growing the crop in the grassy areas, provided the seedings.

“Since we started, it has been a good project,” Emmanuel Morlu, a cocoa farmer in Bambudu, a village in the Lower Rankollie clan, tells The DayLight in an interview. “People embraced the work and we have been working. We saw it as beneficial to us because it is not only in the forest that we can grow cocoa.”    

All about the cocoa agroforestry program has been rosy, though. Farmers were reluctant when it was introduced in 2019 and now they are in a battle with the hostile grassland. Most of Morlu’s 5,500 cocoa seedlings are not thriving in the savannah, according to him, because of insufficient shade trees. Some of the shade trees he planted have not grown.

Morlu’s farm seems to be a battleground just as he puts it. Shrubs of young cocoa trees with yellowish and dried leaves are swamped and dwarfed by tall sunbaked, sugarcane-like grasses. He points to a stunted cocoa shrub, saying it was dying. He and other farmers are facing difficulties, as they are new to planting in the savannah, but says his mind is already made up.

“We are not going to go back to the forest. We have the knowledge already,” he tells me. “Also, it will help us reduce fire outbreaks.”

Bushfire has been another problem farmers here have had to face, even before the civil war. Fueled by the savannah, wildfire has destroyed farms in the region for decades, leaving local authorities grappling with a solution. In one of the worst incidences in March 2018, thousands of acres of farmland were destroyed in Kpandu and Kendema in the Tengia clan. Fifty acres of the FDA’s afforestation and reforestation plantation—established in 2011  as part of a 1986 scheme to fight the fire—were burnt. Some blame careless villagers and travelers. Others say climate change, which has led to prolonged dried seasons and patchy rainfalls nationwide.

So, a year later, local authorities, chiefs and elders passed the Fire “Control Constitution/Laws” after four years of review. Though it was not created by an act of the Legislature, authorities are enforcing it.

It prohibits people from traveling with fire during the dry season, smoking on highways and unauthorized burning of farms. It mandates every farmer to cut a 10-meter buffer—locally called fire lines—between their farms, the forest and other farms.  Violators face fines between L$1,500 and L$5,000.

There have been improvements, with just one fire outbreak in the last three years, according to Moses Sonjor, assistant statutory superintendent for development. “It is not an event,” says Sonjor. “I am really satisfied.”

Just as cocoa farmers are leaving the upland forest for the savannah land, so are rice farmers for swamplands. Years of poor farming practices did not only cut trees but also diminished the fertility of the district’s soil, according to the land-use study conducted by IDH, which works with the farmers to promote sustainable, community-centered agricultural investment in Liberia.

The swamp-rice program is quite ambitious. One thousand farmers are leading that shift to the wetlands, which make up 11.9 percent of Foya. The target is 10,000 farmers on 80 hectares of swampland, according to Kettor. They can produce three times a year, increasing their yield from 2.2 metric tons to 4.5 metric tons per acre a year, says Mohammed Kamara, the CEO of the Agricultural Infrastructural and Development Company (AIIC), which gives the farmers the rice seedlings. That is more than a 100 percent increment in their previous yield in montane forest. AIIC also assists the farmers in tilling the swamp and milling the rice they produce.

Farmers have been encouraged to leave the forest for swamps where they are expected to triple their yields in a scheme to combat deforestation. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue

Wetlands have been used for agricultural purposes for thousands of years, helping to provide clean water, retaining soil and cycling nutrients. That is the case in Foya, too, just that that tradition bears scars of the civil war. Irrigation dams that stored and supplied water to the swamps were destroyed. Warehouses, including that of Intofawor—Liberia’s oldest cooperative—were looted. So were powerhouses that supplied electricity and factories that milled palm oil, cocoa beans and rice.

Now, with the help of IDH and AIIC, three of 10 damaged dams have been repaired and are functioning. The farmers have planted rice on 20 acres of swampland, with that expected to increase to 80 acres, Kettor says. The price of locally produced rice has dropped from L$3,500 to L$1,500 for a 25-kilogram bag, boosting local consumption.

The farmers The DayLight interviewed show no sign of fear that the NGO, the investors, or local authorities will exploit them. Liberia’s history is replete with government-aided concessional land grabs that abuse the rights of local communities, destroyed their livelihood and take their land. However, the Production Protection Inclusion (PPI) project protects them. Though Teogbroma and AIIC provide them with cocoa and rice seedlings, the farmers are not compelled to sell their produce to the companies as per the terms of the project.  And all six clans in Foya have formalized ownership of their ancestral land, guaranteed in the Land Rights Act of 2018.

“We are teaching [our farmers] how to stand by themselves, to be self-sustainable,” says Kumbah Saah, chairperson of Foya Rural Women Cooperative of 52 women and four men, involved in cocoa, palm, rice and vegetable farming. “Everybody knows that we are fighting the savannah and climate change  for the sake of our children.”

Farmers on their farm in a swamp in Foya, Lofa County. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue

Funding for this story was provided by the Resilience Journalism and Climate Change Fellowship Program of the Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism CYNY Foundation, Inc.   

Dutch Bank Pulls Out of Probe Into Alleged Deforestation and Land Grab in Liberia

0

Top: Deforestation is associated with the agricultural sector in Liberia. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By Gabriel M. Dixon  

MONROVIA – Dutch Bank, ING, has backed down from an OECD investigation into a complaint filed by NGOs that accused it of supporting companies that are allegedly clearing forests and grabbing land in Liberia and other parts of the world.    

A statement by the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which looks into OECD matters, on April 7 said “No agreement could be reached between the parties [ Friends of the Earth and partners vs. ING]” after several months of negotiations.

Sustainable Development Institute (SDI), its Dutch and Indonesian affiliates, Friend of the Earth Netherlands and WAHLI complained in July 2019 that ING bank allegedly violated OECD’s guidelines.

“ING has breached several provisions of the OECD Guidelines by contributing to specific adverse environmental, human rights, and labor rights impacts caused by subsidiaries of ING’s clients Noble Group Ltd., Bollore Group/Socfin Group S.A., and Wilmar International Ltd,” stated the complaint in summary.

In January 2020, the OECD started to look into the complaint and concluded that it  “merited further consideration.”  The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is an international body that issues guidelines and recommendations to multinational enterprises for responsible business conduct. The body works with governments, decision-makers, and citizens on establishing international standards and best practices on a range of issues including the environment.  Its guidelines are, however, not binding.  

ING denies any wrongdoing, saying, “The bank refused to accept any liabilities” and “opined there are no harms to which [it] contributed.”

The Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs expressed regret the mediation did not continue.  “Efforts to bring (the) parties to an agreement on possible improvements of ING’s due diligence policies and practices regarding palm oil, and to assess the enterprise’s involvement with the actual or potential adverse impacts identified, in order to determine the appropriate responses, ended prematurely,” it said.

The international standards-setting body, therefore, concluded that “No agreement could be reached between the parties… on the question whether and to what extent there was a responsibility of ING to cease its (possible) contribution and to contribute to remedying the adverse impacts.”  

The petitioners represent communities and individuals in Africa and Asia where companies Like Wilmar/SICFA, Bollore Group/Socfin, and GAR run various oil palm and rubber plantations funded by investments from ING bank and other financial institutions. At the time of their complaint, the three NGOs sought “to ensure that oil palm companies operate within the confines of the Liberian laws and international standards on human rights and the environment,” stated James Otto-lead campaigner for SDI. 

An earlier report by FoE showed how Dutch banks heaped investments in multinationals like GAR, Wilmar, the Bolloré Group, and SOCFIN Group to fund their operations in Liberia and countries in Africa and Asia.  Subsidiaries of those foreign companies are accused of carrying out deforestation, land grab, and human rights violations. In a few cases, some were found guilty by the RSPO and other international regulators.

The Maryland Oil Palm Plantation and the Cavalla Rubber Corporation,  both of whom are owned and run by SIFCA, a subsidiary of Wilmar, were found to have engaged in deforestation and human rights violations including killing in Maryland County. SIFCA’s total investment in MOPP is about US$203 million. The investment was largely funded by ING bank.   

“ING bank chooses to continue deforestation and human rights violations on the palm oil plantations in which they invest money [leaving] affected residents in Liberia, Indonesia, Cameroon, and Sierra Leone… empty-handed,” Friends of the Earth said in the release responding to ING’s pullout.  

“The unilateral withdrawal from Dutch ING bank is outrageous……… This shows the urgent need for regulating the financial sector…,” said Wouter Kolk, a senior campaigner at Friends of the Earth.

The DayLight has reached out to ING bank for comment on the statement released by the office of OECD in the Netherlands and the claims made by Friend of the Earth in its news release.  

The bank’s action comes at a time when the UN and climate scientists continue to warn the world of the fast-increasing impact of climate change and the ability of many communities to adapt. According to the Union of Concerned Scientists,  deforestation and forest degradation now constitutes 10 percent of global warming.  Environmentalists agree that the clearing of forests for agriculture and mining projects leads to emissions of high CO2 into the air. 

James Otto, lead campaigner at SDI called on the Dutch government to “ensure justice and redress” for victims in Liberia.

“We will continue to work with local communities to identify other ways to hold ING bank and other financiers to account,” Otto said in a statement. “They can walk away from the table but not from having to face the responsibility of their clients’ misconduct.”

Farmers to Complain Against Oil Palm Company to Global Watchdog

0

Top: An Equatorial Palm Oil truck transports palm nuts at the company’s Palm Bay estate. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By Emmanuel Sherman

JOGBAHN CLAN, Grand Bassa County – last year, there were hopes after farmers and Equatorial Palm Oil (EPO) began negotiation to resolve a conflict between the pair over a controversial deal that saw the company pay for their crops.

But that negotiation has failed and the farmers have told The DayLight they would file a complaint against EPO with the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), the global watchdog for the commodity if they do not get redress.  

“The proposals from the communities were all denied by the company,” says James Otto of the Sustainable Development Institute (SDI), an NGO working with the villagers, in an interview with The DayLight.

The RSPO’s principles and criteria call for its member companies to respect communities’ free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) before planting palm trees on lands they occupy.

“The communities think that these processes were not followed after the company made a series of unrealistic promises to them,” adds Otto.

The farmers say they are seeking the intervention of local and county authorities on the matter, a prerequisite for lodging complaints with the global certification scheme.  

“If nothing is done, we will go to RSPO,” says Luke Paye Toe, the chairman of the aggrieved farmers.  

The conflict started in 2016 when EPO compensated farmers from five communities: Gmene, Kampala, Wesseh Village, Paye Town, and Morb Town. EPO and the Liberian government had signed a 50-year agreement in 2008 for the company to expand its plantation to cover 169, 000 hectares in Grand Bassa, River Cess, and Sinoe counties. It was a transfer and extension of a 1965 agreement between the country and LIBINCO, whose plantations were destroyed during the Liberian Civil War. EPO had to pay the farmers for their crops before clearing them to replant palm trees. 

But the farmers allege they were cheated in the deal. They accuse EPO of using previous government-approved prices that were higher to seal the deal but paid them according to new prices that were low.   

The previous one, for instance, had rubber at US$97.92 for a mature tree—the villagers are predominant rubber farmers—but that was reduced to just US$6. The change also affected other crops, including sugarcane from US$0.54 a stick to US$6 an acre, and banana from US$1.69 to US$3 for several shrubs.

The government had lowered the compensation of the crops to “spur development,” a June 6, 2014 public notice released by the Ministry of Agriculture said.

“This action has been taken in furtherance of the Agenda for Transformation for the effective development of the agriculture sector with reference to the Millennium Development Goals and pushing the post-2015 development agenda,” it added.

The farmers had anticipated US$2 million for rubber alone but received US$224,597 for all their crops in the end. They demand a balance of over US$1.7 million or a negotiated settlement.  

“They are not willing to pay us,” says Hillary Gbah of Gmene Town, who received US$14,574, according to records of the payment seen by The DayLight, but expected to get US$237,847. “We will take them to task.”

EPO denies any wrongdoing, saying they compensated the farmers according to the government-set prices. “It is their decision to go to the RSPO,” says Jasvinder Singh, EPO’s compliance manager.    

Farmers hold a meeting over Equatorial Palm Oil’s controversial compensation of their crops in 2016. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue

The farmers have written the National Bureau of Concessions (NBC), Gbehzohngar Findley, former President Pro Tempore of the Liberian Senate, and county officials on the matter. 

“We the five communities… wish to formally bring to your attention our hurts and betrayal on the part of EPO to deliver our just and fair benefits, regarding the use of our land,” their letter to the Grand Bassa Legislative Caucus reads.

“We the farmers and community members of the five… communities are complaining the company to you and hope that you will take the needed actions in addressing our concerns,” it adds.   

EPO is a member of the RSPO through its parent company Kuala Lumpur Kepong Berhad (KLK) of Malaysia, one of the oldest and largest multinational palm oil companies in the world. Not being in compliance with the watchdog’s standards could hurt its standing on the Alternative Investment Market (AIM) of the London Stock Exchange (LSE), where it is listed.     

It would not be the first complaint involving EPO at the RSPO.  In 2013, other towns in Jogbahn Clan filed a complaint against it for an alleged land grab but the watchdog cleared the company of that accusation. Ironically, the five communities in the current controversy did not have issues with the company and did not participate in the 2013 complaint.

“The new planting of 1,570 hectares is not in the disputed area claimed by the Joghban Clan,” the RSPO said at the time. However, it mandated EPO to stop development in disputed areas and address its encroachment into Nnuhn and Qwrakpojilain villages. Afterward, the communities and the clan participated in demarcating their boundaries and the dispute was resolved.

Funding for this story was provided by the Green Livelihood Alliance (GLA 2.0) through the Community Rights and Corporate Governance Program of the Sustainable Development Institute. The DayLight maintained complete editorial independence over the story’s content.

Community Leader Urges Local Officials To Stay Off Forest Matters

0

Top: Newly felled and marked logs from the Bond Mandingo Forest in Gbarpolu County. The DayLight/James Harding Giahyue


By Henry Gboluma

BOPOLU, Gbarpolu County – A community forest leadership has cautioned county officials and residents to stay away from matters of the management of forest resources. 

Recently, Joseph Akoi, Assistant Development Superintendent of Gbarpolu threatened to prevent Indo Africa Plantation Limited from transporting logs from the Bondi Mandingo Community Forest. Akoi demanded the Singaporean logging company pay the community its benefit before being taking logs it had felled there for shipment. The company owes the communities thousands of United States dollars and has yet to fulfill the commitment it made to help develop its towns and villages.    

But making remarks at a daylong training organized by the forest governance program of the Sustainable Development Institute (SDI), Mark Dennis, the community forest management body (CFMB), said Akoi and King were interfering in community forest matters.

“Sometimes they want us to do something outside of the law, but we are finding it difficult to bend the law,” said Dennis. “We are recommending that our county authorities and some influential leaders in our communities be educated about the law.”

Dennis acknowledged the company has not fulfilled its promises made to the communities but warned interference could worsen the situation.  

Residents have a say in community forestry but through recognized bodies.

The Community Rights Law of 2009 with Respect to Forest Lands empowers the community assembly—comprising representatives from villages affected by logging operations—the executive committee of the assembly and the CFMB Dennis heads to handle such matters. Neither Akoi nor King is a member of any of the groups.  

If there is a conflict between a community and a company only the Forestry Development Authority (FDA) should intervene. In the case where parties to the dispute cannot resolve the matter goes to arbitration or to court.  

The event Dennis spoke at was meant to train members of Bondi Mandingo, Korninga A, and Korninga B community forests, who have all had their share of conflict with logging companies.  The gathering, which brought together representatives of the civil society, donors, and local leaders, also forms part of the Legal Foundation for Sustainable Forests and Livelihoods project for logging affected communities being implemented by the Sustainable Development Institute (SDI). Participants gained new skills in resolving conflicts, using the alternative disputes resolution (ADR) mechanism.  

ADR is the procedure by which disputes are settled without litigation. These include arbitration, mediation, or negotiation. The method has been widely used to settle community disputes because it is less costly and yields a speedy outcome.

“We want to ensure that community forests are stronger and contribute more effectively to reducing deforestation, conserving biodiversity, and generating sustainable economic development in Liberia,” said Wilfred Gray-Johnson, the Executive Director of SDI.  

“This is helping to increase community voices in forest governance by identifying and elevating them at the national level, while at the same time finding ways to solve them all together,” he added.

Podcasts